I have to say, I was disappointed with this product. I've been using Clinique Rinse Off for years, but after I've read raving reviews on this eye makeup remover, I decided to give it a try as to a cheeper altrenative. And I didn't like it at all. Here come the reasons. 1). It is very oily. It washes off quite easily, but i hated that feeling of oiliness around my eyes even for 10 seconds. 2). It does not remove the makeup completely!! ANd I've used Almay One Coat Mascara (no eye shadow or liner whatsoever) which is the same brand!!! I guess I should stop trying to find drugstore products with high-end quality. IMHO, you always get what you pay for.