This is the only mascara I've tried that doesn't smudge under my eyes! It's *very* natural looking, so I would avoid this if you want dramatic lashes. Like others have already mentioned, it is extremely lightweight and it makes your lashes soft. I deducted 1 point because it flakes a tiny bit and uncurls my lashes. However, I'll be sticking to this mascara until I find another one that is smudgeproof!

by Sandy on Feb 04th 2001