I gave this product a 2 because it is the most intensely flavored, true-to-nature strawberry gloss I've tried. It tastes like juice on my lips. Unfortunately, the texture is awful. The product looks like a lava lamp, with two colors of liquid (clear and red) swirling around the bottle but never blending. The manufacturer must have had to compromise product quality to achieve this effect, because the gloss itself is runny, thin, and soaks right into the lips instead of providing shine. It's kind of like using baby oil. You could never use this with a lipliner or over lipstick, because it would bleed like crazy.