Well, I decided not to recommend this because there are better cleansers out there IMHO. It did not lather up as I had expected. Secondly, it did not remove all of my makeup. And then, it left an undesirable greasy film on my face after I rinsed. I felt reluctant to give it less than a 3, because it did not leave my skin dry and taut, and it did have a pleasant orange fragrance. But there are better cleansers on the market and you don't need to look too far.