I am going to return this eye shadow after all because the color is just too awful to be used. In the store, it looked sord of like a ligth blueish grey which was pretty. However, it was really an ugly muddy green under the sunlight and I looked like a ghost afterward. Personally, I like many of the products from CARGO but this one is really an exception. I give it a 2 for its silky finish and cute container.