I bought this in Buff Beige and Classic Ivory. It was hard to decide what color to get and my color in CG is somewhere between Ivory, Classic Ivory and Buff Beige in all the foundations. As it turns out the classic Ivory was very whitish on me and covered but turned my dark circles to gray. The Buff Beige is the right color, though, and does cover darkness well, true to ther reports I've read. I have a dark streak under one eye, more than a dark circle, and it is definitely less noticeable today. I gave this a 4 because it does have a whitish quality. If you are chosing between 2 shades, I would try the darker choice first, based on my experience. My impression so far is that this covers better than Revlon Luminous touch or avon Beyond color, without being yellow or peachy. The consistency is not thin, but it isn't thick. I haven't noticed it settling in the lines under my eyes.
