Subtle but Pretty
Bought on a whim, I was originally looking for a cream eye shadow. The closest I found was Cover Girl Eyeslick Gel Eyeliner. So why not, it's only $5. Picked up one in the color "Pewter", which is a grayish brown. Very neutral but pretty.
I tried it the next day and here's what I got:
Pros: The color was absolutely pretty. I think it’s a great neutral for anyone with ivory/pale skin. It had a nice shine (without cheesy glitter). Feel nice and smooth.
Cons: Hard to get on. You had to go over the same spot 2-3 times to really see the color.
All in all, it’s a good product for what it’s worth. I love the color.