Okay me and my mom bought this same mascara. And my mom have short thin lashes. But I have pretty nice long normal lashes. When I tried this mascara it was alright. It made my lashes a pinch longer and that was it. On the other hand when my mom tried it it made her lashes long and thick. So I gave this product a 5 cause it did a good job on her lashes. But since my lashes are naturally long and a little thick I didn't really see a difference in mine.
