I got this cos I'm in search of a eye liner to try out. This is my first eye liner and I do not know whether to like it or not. It applied in a breeze but a few minutes later, I begin to notice that it smudges by itself easily. But this can be erase easily with a q-tip or fingers. The colour I bought was walnut brown, which is for everyday use. But the staying power does not last the whole day. It comes with a refil too! Worth the try if you are a beginner in eye liners!