Thank goodness this was only a GWP, because I would definitely take it back for a full refund. The concept is good, but the wand style eyeshadow has many disadvantages IMHO. Lack of control is one. Too much product gets on the wand and because this product tends to spread easily, something intended for the lower mobile lid will end up being all over the eye. The colour I received is Rose. It's a peachy rose with shimmer that would look better as a lipgloss. The colour made me look tired and looked as though my lids were irritated. Maybe a different colour would change my mind, but I won't be going out of my way to buy it.