I got this lipstick yesterday because I wanted something with sunscreen, and it's not all that bad. The formula is nice and lasts for a few hours, and isn't drying or anything bad, but the reason I gave it a 4 is because I didn't really like the color. Girlie is a sheer nudey pink with a hint of frost and it made my lips look washed out, but still I am going to buy this in another color.