Hated this stuff from the very first time I used it. Did nothing to emphasize my lashes, only made them wet and heavy. I didn't expect it to magically curl my lashes, but I did expect it to make my lashes look longer. It's very similar to Maybelline's Great Lash mascara. Very wet and gloppy. I'll never understand why Jane discontinued Flashes mascara. IMO, it was far superior to Fan Club.