I've had this sample lipliner for ages but never really used it because I just am not lipliner person.
I have used it enough on whims so it was worn down enough to need sharpening.
I have to say its a really nice colour (Fraichelle-a rosy colour with brown undertones) and gives a soft matte coverage but what I am mostly reviewing is how great it is to sharpen. Most pencils when you sharpen them flake and chip off wooden bits that stick to the sharpener and the liner. Not this one though. It was so nice to sharpen. The shavings came off in one smooth curl and had a nice density to it so you could pull it off easily without it breaking onto the liner. Nice!