This is a great lip liner! A little spendy, but it has excellent color, staying power, and smoothness of application. I have the color Red Chocolate, and it's the perfect browned-down natural muted red for application underneath red lippies (reds tend to go fuchsia on me, so I need to line underneath with a dark pencil to prevent that) or brown lippies -- it's a very natural color, so it goes with lots of different lipsticks. The texture of the pencil is very smooth and not really creamy, but almost powdery smooth. The only critique I'd give this product is that it's in pencil form, but in a wood pencil -- I'd prefer an automatic pencil form that doesn't need sharpening -- I hate wasting any product by sharpening, and sometimes the point gets dulled in a wood lip pencil.

by iCompact Member on Sep 20th 2000