This mascara did nothing for my eyelashes. Although right after application my lashes did look slightly thicker,longer and of more volume, somehow at the end of the day the effects were all gone. However this mascara did not smudge (unlike many w/p ones I tried), clump or irritate my eyes, but it did practically nothing to my eyelashes.Maybellines' Full n Soft would win hands down compared to this product, except that the Maybelline one would smudge a little.