I truly love this mascara and I was surprised to see such a wide mix of varying reviews of this product. I like this mascara because it doesn't clump or flake. It doesn't come on to heavy and it's easy to get off. Yes, I wish it curled better, but so far no mascara really curls all that well and this does a pretty good job for whats available. I love this mascara and I am on my 6th bottle. I took one point off because your lashes aren't super curly, just slightly.