First, let me say that I have pathetic eyelashes--they are sparse, thin, short, and they stick straight out! Having said that, I obviously need a lot help from my mascara! Well, unfortunately, Voluminous does not fit the bill. Its bad points--too heavy, uncurled my lashes, slightly fake looking, and slightly clumpy. Its plus point--it does indeed add volume.
I won't re-purchase this, although it might be good for someone whose lashes don't get weighed down easily.