I really like this mascara. I'm a fan of l'oreal products and this is no exception. The mascara shows up very well and it's easy to apply. I'm pretty sure it's water proof and it's also easy to take off. I like this mascara because of the colour and since I don't have very long and dramatic lashes, this mascara really adds colour and length. The only thing that I don't like about this product is that it sometimes sticks lashes together if you add too much at a time and it can also creates small clumps at the bottom of your lashes. But, I've tried my mascaras and I've also come back to this one. I do recommend this product because of the colour and the application. It's a very nice mascara and it works well with an eye lash curler.