I have such oily eyelids and have tried many eye bases to no advail! I have been reading about Untitled paint by MAC so I finally bought it.
Well, not only is this a great neutral base (doesn't look as orange in person as it does on website)but it stays allll day and holds my eyeshadow that I put on top! This is the first base that stays on my oily lids all day.
I am one of the rare people who don't care for MAC paints as I find them too frosty, but I am 40 and I look better in mattes. I don't find this color frosty and I am using it more to hold my eyeshadow all day.
I love this product and highly recommend to those of you with oily eye lids to hold your eyeshadow color all day or if you just want a great neutral base eyeshadow color, this is the one!