This is the most beautiful color ever (dark, kinda rosey) in the tube. However, on my lips its some coral-ish pink that looks gross as hell. It's waaay too shiny and metallic for me... and oh god, the smell is horrible. I don't know if I got a re-formulated one (I bought it like the second week of October) but the stuff smells like soap. I got a headache from the sickening smell, and I'm not the type to get headaches from fragrances. I do like the brush applicator though. But yeah. Steeeer clear of this mis-purchase.