I think I've finally found my perfect mascara. And I've tried a lot - Maybelline Great Lash and Full and Soft and Volume Express and Lash Discovery; Jane Wondercurl; Loreal Lash Out and Featherlash and Intensifique; Almay One Coat and Amazing Lash; OoO Beauty; Clinque Naturally Glossy and Long Stemmed; Max Factor 2000K; Estee Lauder More Than Mascara; Lancome Definicils - these are the ones I can name off the top of my head. There are probably some others that I forgot.
But Prolash has everything I want - thickening and lengthening; can wear one coat for a natural look, or build up for a dramatic look. AND NO SMUDGING! I have combo skin, and when I yawn my eyes water, so it's a major score to find a mascara that doesn't smudge on me. And for $9.00 it's moderately priced, especially when compared to my last favorite, Lancome's Definicils, which costs $20.
MAC Prolash is definitely a keeper for me.