out of all the ones i try, including diorfic from CD, shiseido waterproof mascara, and drama cils from chanel..i find this one, pro lash from MAC, the best..i was surprised with the price cos it's so low..i give it a real plus because it didn't give me a black rim after a whole night of partying..and it really lengthen my lashes too..this thing doesn't smear, clump, flake..it's a high quality mascara to keep
