This eyeliner is so good! It goes on pretty easy and looks better on me than the pencil eyeliners. If the line is too crooked I just use a damp (not soaking wet) Q-Tip and fix it. It so easy. I got the black shade. I cannot believe I didnt try liquid eyeliners until now! Boy was I missing out! BTW, this does come off easily (like with water) so it is definetly not waterproof, but its an awesome liner.