I have never given anything a 5 but this is one of my favorite products.It layers on light and you keep adding more for greater coverage. I have medium/light skin and used Soft Cameo which I found looks very natural.Despite some of the negative reviews for this product I highly recommend it for people who dont have too much time to perfect their look in the morning, as it is almost flawless to apply.Skin looks soft, dewy and youthful.