This isn't a bad product at all. In fact, if the name weren't "wet shine" i probably would have given it a four or five. It didn't seem to shine at all!! isn't that the whole point of this stuff? It looked pretty matte on me. Maybe the color i bought (coffee splash) was a lil too dark to have any shine. despite the lack of shine, it felt lightweight and had nice color. if you want to see this stuff shine, i suggest you buy one of the lighter shades.