This mascara is very nice! Though its Sarah Michelle Gellar commercials do typically exaggerate the product's abilities, this mascara does live up to the "full" part of its name, making my sparse lashes thicker and more widely spread apart...I love the brush it comes with! It doesn't live up to the Soft part, though, but I don't think any proper mascara can. Its only drawback is how it tends to smudge at the end of the day, but I can overlook that and still give it a confident 4.