Overall I was a bit disappointed about this mascara after all the raves for this product. The good points: It really made my lashes look fuller, longer, thicker, no clumping and yet the lashes still remains soft. Also, the waterproof version does last up the whole day. It washes off quite easily with a makeup remover as compared to Maybelline's wonder curl in waterproof. The bad points: It did not really look too natural somehow maybe coz it lacked adequate definition. The wand is a bit too fat, causing some of the mascara to land up on my eyelids during application. It also flakes when I apply it, but this occurs only during application. I would think wonder curl (waterproof) would be a better product than this if u are looking for something more natural.