I feel this mascara is very clean, no clumps at all. It did define my lash and add volume and length to it at the same time. But i dont feel my lash is soft at all. Also the brush seems too big. So when i applying it the colour always goes onto my upper eyelid.
I give it a 4 because i feel this mascara takes at least 2 layers in order too notice the difference. More than 3 layers to create a dramatic effect which takes a bit of times.