I have always wanted to try Great Lash b/c of all the raves and I needed some waterproof mascara to wear to a pool party, so I picked this up. I like the color and that it doesn't flake or smudge, but it clumps a little bit, so I have to comb through with a lash comb. Plus, its not really waterproof because I took a shower to test it and its was smeared all down around my eyes. I think once it is used up I might try the regular formula w/ the curved brush b/c my lashes tend to do better with washable mascara. This might work better for some people.