This is not a good mascara. I don't really understand why magazine editors rave about it. *confused*
I got this as a gift with purchase at London Drugs. It doesn't lengthen nor thicken very much. The formula is too wet and it's easily smudged right after application. Actually, this mascara smudged on me during the day long after drying!!! I had dark smudges under my eyes in about an hour after applying it. I give this product a one because it is not clumpy.