another mascara to throw away. initially i loved this product. the brush was perfect, small enough to get everything and seperate my lashes. the formula was thin enough for me and it was truly the blackest black mascara i have seen. it coated my entire lashes which i've had problems with before. it was love at first site, but then this lil rascal decided to let its true colors show. the longer i used it the more watery the formula seemed to become, in fact i could barely coat my lash w/o gettin half of my eyelid as well. mistakes were not easily cleaned up, instead a black smudge wanted to remain. tho it wasn't waterproof it wouldn't wash off....wait..it would wash off my lashes, but almost impossible to remove the black stain around my eyes...and smudged..and ran...and well..i don't think i hafta go on. save your money folks!