In terms of thickening and lengthening, the results were pretty decent but the staying power is not too good. I had smudges under my eyes a half hour later and my skin isn't oily. It also de-curled my lashes and it's quite hard to remove. I don't think I've really been satisfied w/ any of Maybelline's mascara, so far. And w/ all mascaras, usually the effects come from the brush, not the formula. I think Full n' Soft is one of the best and I like it, but if the company improves their formula I'll consider trying out their mascaras again. I think others w/ naturally curled lashes would have success w/ this mascara.
