I just got this a few days ago in the Brown/Black. It does a nice job of adding volume and length, and doesn't make my lashes feel hard. My lashes looked beautiful! But it has a horrendous smell! Like burning rubber, or tar being laid for construction! It's wretched! But if you can hold your breath for the first few seconds of application, it goes away. I can use this for now but probably won't purchase it again.