I decided to try this because it was so cheap and I wasn't expecting it to be a really good mascara, but I gave it a shot anyways. I got Dark Brown. It goes on smooth and not only did it thicken my lashes, but it also lengthened them while still looking natural. It had minimal clumping and separated beautifully. I also saved the brush from my Full 'n' Soft mascara and rinsed it off and then used it to separate any clumps, which there were hardly any. So for $1.99 I was pretty impressed. Now I can spend 2 bucks on a good mascara instead of like 6 bucks.