I've always used eyeliner and settled with the red pencils by Maybelline but was tired of it always smudging away and creasing so I tried this product. I was initially unimpressed because once it was on the eyes it was non blendable and I wanted the smoky eye look. It just stuck on my lids! 6 months later I came across it again and now I love it. Yes, this is very very difficult to blend but i found that I could create the "smudge" effect by lightly feathering the strokes. It stayed on through an entire 14 hour day and creased only a tiny bit in the inner eye. If you are looking for a more defined eye liner that stays, this is wonderful!

by iCompact Member on Dec 09th 2000