I have to comment that I am pretty pleased with this product. Colorstay is the only mascara that doesn't smear under my eyes and give me racoon eyes by the middle of the day. And, for that I have to give it good marks. My skin is oily and I have long eyelashes and other mascaras just don't work for me. But, this one is truly smear proof. In terms of being superthick, I don't really see a difference in this product that the original mascara. I love to pair the mascara with a thin coat of liquid Colorstay mascara. This and a little lip gloss gives a real, pretty look with lush, looking eyes.

by iCompact Member on Oct 29th 2000