I bought this mascara because it said that it was smudge-proof. The mascara does go on nicely, but I found it a little clumpy and it left my lashes feeling very unnatural and stiff. As far as being smudge-proof, several hours after applying it, it would transfer to my fingers if I were to even touch my eye, it would also rub off on to clothes. Not very smudge-proof at all.

by winde on Mar 06th 2001