I have mixed feelings for this mascara and its either good or bad depending on what you are looking for. Its benefits are that its a very smooth and light formula, totally clump free, and it gives a nice but very subtle shimmer. I however would not buy this mascara again becuase it does nothing to lengthen, thicken, or curl at all even after countless layers. It might work well if you layer it over your regular mascara and I would only recommend buying it if you are attracted to the color flicks and even then you need countless layers for them to show up under bright lights.