I disagree with the reviewer that said this particular color compares with Nars Orgasm without the sparkle. I bought this color based on that suggestion. Tawny is actually quite orange. Orgasm is pinkish, not orange. Orange anything looks horrible with my skintone.
I only gave it a 3 based on color--I bought Pink Rose and would give that a 5--great color. Texture is great for such an inexpensive line!