A HG for me!
I got these on clearance at Meijer, I hope they aren't being discontinued b/c I am in love with them. I got black and brown. The brown is a real deep ink black and the brown is a deep dark brown that still looks brown, not black.
I find these pretty easy to apply and they wear like iron on my lids (I do not have oily lids at all though). I accidently fell asleep one night wearing my black one and it was still there when I woke up in the morning.