I used to love this mascara. It comes in a nice brown, which is hard to find in drugstore mascaras, actually does curl my stick-straight lashes a little, and washes out easily with soap and water, without flaking off during the day. But they changed the formula in the last year. It's now way too wet and to avoid lumps and clumps you have to wipe the wand off before you use it. It still looks good if you're willing to do that, it just drives me crazy because I used to love this!