i would like to give a thumbs up to this product.it does a really good job of thickening up your lashes and it's under $2.aside from the fact that it's not water proof and so you could experience some smudging problems(as i have)i have experienced hardly any negative problems with this product.no clumping and definetely no flaking!if you are looking for a good basic mascara this one's for you.and also it comes in black & brown.

by iCompact Member on Oct 04th 1999